Our Leading Album of 2025: The Artist's Masterpiece Claims the Top Spot.

Initially, this album may look closer to a difficult scholarly challenge than the latest popular music album by an artist who just had a last hit was a collaboration with an international pop star. Broken into 4 separate parts and performed in thirteen languages, we have a head-spinning symphonic opus exploring feminine mystique, religious ascent, and bodily transformation, often by way of the lens of various women saints. The dissolution of a relationship—a theme handled with grounded honesty on another major 2025 album—soars heavenward here, supported by the constant presence of a major orchestra and input from a Pulitzer-winning songwriter among a vast list of contributors. Its sheer ambition alone renders the work of contemporary artists seem rather modest.

Transcending Academic Pretense

That this album succeeds in escape dry academic chin-stroking feels almost miraculous, and complete praise going to Rosalía. Although it's not the first time album to fuse the past and modern styles, its ambitions feel far higher here, with the balancing act far more precarious. The element that truly elevates her fourth album, outside of its complex melodies, dense arrangements, and engrained theatricality, proves to be an essential spirit of playfulness. Much like the legendary Björk during her height, you find a captivating quality to Rosalía's voice which sweeps you up in its tornado. Even when she's tearing hearts apart, the listener still desire to be right there for the journey.

A Signature Moment of Joy

This playful energy comes forth brightly on the stunning Italian song about Saint Clare. It bathes in a string-drenched melancholy for several minutes. Suddenly, all the music falls away, and there's a spontaneous laugh followed by a comment before a hilariously over-the-top string surge crashes in like comedic impact. The song then segues to the frenetic single featuring racing orchestration, a powerful choir, and a surprise appearance from none other than Björk.

"The magic with Lux lies in the listener rarely exactly understand—or even want to predict—where it is going to next."

Almost every song finishes in a completely distinct place from how it began. A track examines the fleeting trappings of fame with a featherlight orchestration only to collapsing into electronic cacophony. Another, a cut echoing her earlier rhythmic work begins off dark and brooding, with prowling beats, until sudden flamenco rhythms and an angelic chorus arrive to soften its rough corners.

The Bridge Between Art and Accessibility

A key achievement of Lux is straddling the gap of radical experimentation and broad appeal. It is little coincidence that it has achieved her highest-charting work to crack the upper reaches of key charts: at its core a suite of truly undeniable pop songs. A song performed primarily in English swells around a refrain that seems to collect increasingly infectious hooks as it spins skyward. That feat is repeated on a different powerful track that expands and constricts, intertwining layered tunes as an intricate weave.

  • A dance-infused song seduces via its jaunty, Disney-adjacent flair and a chant-along chorus.
  • In its words, it aligns with pop culture impact of contemporary heartbreak songs, eviscerating a former partner labeled an "emotional terrorist".
  • Across the album, the singing carry a sharp edge, akin to a storybook character concealing a knife: "Top prize in acting like a motherfucker / You've won the trophy of disappointment."

A Maximalist Banquet for the Ears

Lux is popular music on a maximalist scale, a hungry grasp for high Art in an era of impending AI-generated sameness. It rejects self-absorption in favor of sublime elevation, creating an over-the-top drama that masterfully controls its own built-in excess. It is a deep source of hidden treasure that takes time to fully mine but never feels like a chore. While other big pop albums of the year felt like feasting on scraps, Lux offers a lavish banquet where the characters at the table, perhaps tipsy on holy wine, flit from conversations about historical saints, the galvanizing sensation of heartbreaking sadness, and shared gossip about useless men. It is a contemporary theatrical production from pop's most endlessly creative practitioner.

Debra Holland
Debra Holland

A tech journalist and AI researcher with over a decade of experience covering emerging technologies and their impact on society.